It does not matter how much is forgiven and it really does not matter the reason. Forgiving student loans is a divisive issue. There is one main group that will directly benefit from student loan forgiveness. This group includes those for whom student loans are forgiven. On the other hand, there will aways be a number of groups that will be aggrieved. This group of the aggrieved includes at least those who have paid off their student loans, those who never took out student loans and those who did not have the opportunity to take out student loans because they did not attend college.
Student Loan Forgiveness
There is a student loan problem. Some students were victims of predatory lending from opportunist institutions. In some cases, students were given loans and then obtained worthless degrees. In some cases, the institutions were not up to par academically. For some, the college was closed down and students were stuck with student loans but no degree. For others, student loan terms were not clearly explained and students now owe more than they borrowed. In all cases, for those affected, it is likely that they are stuck with a mountain of student loans and no true path to ever pay off the borrowed amount plus the accruing interest.
On balance, should these students have done their due diligence? Should these students have read the fine print and better understood what they were signing up for? Also, should there have been more government oversight to prevent institutions from selling these subprime student loans to vulnerable students? Something to think about.
Students Who Paid Back Their Student Loans
There are some students and adults who have now paid back their student loans. Essentially, they made it a priority to not take out more than they needed during their school years. Many of these individuals did not attend their dream school because of the cost. Instead, they settled for a less expensive option. They may have also worked extra jobs. Some did not take fancy spring break trips while in college. Others have forgone buying nicer homes or cars. Instead of spending, these students were cost conscious. They buckled down and payed back their student loans.
How would you feel if you were one of these students when you hear of others getting student loan forgiveness? You will likely feel robbed. You have made the sacrifices and paid back what you owed. Now, you are being penalized for your diligence, being proactive and responsible. Would you view this a being fair?
Students Who Did Not Take Out Student Loans
Let’s face it, we live in an unequal society. There are a group of students who attended college and did not have the need to take out student loans. This could have been a result of their parents saving over time and allocating funds specifically for college. For others, their parents were in the position to pay their tuition as they went through college. Still, there are many who simply worked during college and were able to make enough to pay their costs or obtained scholarships.
For those who prepaid for college, those who worked multiple jobs to pay their tuition, and those who studied and obtained scholarships, how is student loan forgiveness viewed? Will they view student loan forgiveness as a penalty? Why work hard during college and forgo all the parties, why prepay for college, why work hard and obtain scholarships when the student loans will be forgiven anyway?
Those Who Did Not Attend College
Of the groups that will likely view student loan forgiveness in a bad light, those who did not attend college will likely be the most upset. They are the most likely to be upset because as tax payers, they may view student loan forgiveness as paying for something they did not have the opportunity to part take in. These individuals are essentially paying for someone else’s college education or mistake. They may also see student loan forgiveness being applied to college educated citizens as causing a further divide between the have and the have nots. Some who will be helped by student loan forgiveness, where they attended reputable colleges, may end up earning more than those who did not attend college. So in effect, as a tax payer, those who did not attend college would be further subsidizing these individual’s lifestyle. For many, this will be viewed as being unfair.
The Greater Good
No matter your stance on student loan forgiveness, one thing to consider in this student loan forgiveness debate is the greater good. Will forgiving a portion of student loans help the overall society in general terms. If citizens are not buried by student loan payments, will this translate into increase economic activity as more funds will be available to spend. If this works perfectly, all of society will benefit. However, will this affect personal responsibility and the motivation to live within ones means if there is a possibility that your debt will be forgiven?
Whatever the decision with regard to student loan forgiveness, one thing is for sure, the debate will continue.
Follow me on Twitter @JoToFI_com
Follow me on Instagram @JoToFI_com